Phoenix (Marvel Masterpieces), 1993

The New Mutants #98, 1991 (1st appearance of Deadpool)

Reign of the Supermen, 1993

 

Shelly (Youngblood card series), 1992

AHHHH WHAT AHHHH

Shaft, seen here after plucking his eyes out after looking at Shelly's crazy face.

Wolverine and Nightcrawler, 1992

 

Newmen #1, 1994

Hello, Newmen.

Girth

Image Comics card (Wizard insert), 1992

Fun fact: Jim Valentino has no teeth.